Allowing uncertainty

Page contents

Page contents

Click on the links below to jump to the respective piece of content on this page.

Getting better information by not pushing for answers.

First published
Written by College of Policing
Obtaining initial accounts

Allowing uncertainty – guideline

If a witness is unable to be specific then the officer or staff should not push them to provide an answer.

Evidence summary

 Evidence drawn from three experiments using student samples indicated that allowing interviewees to provide 'don’t know' responses improved recall accuracy, particularly when there was a delay between witnessing an event and questioning. Five other laboratory-based experiments that used computer-administered questioning indicated that, when forced to give more specific answers to questions, witnesses are less accurate than when able to choose how specific their answers are.

Empirical evidence
Moderate
Practitioner evidence
Not available

Avoid forced answers

Research shows that witnesses are less accurate when forced to give more specific answers to questions than when they are able to choose how specific they are. Forcing a witness to give a response should therefore be avoided. For example, when estimating the time of an incident, witnesses should be allowed to be as precise as they like. If a witness says an event was between two and three hours ago, they should not be pushed for a precise time as they may give false information.

If there is a need to push for a more specific answer for operational reasons, the witness should be asked how sure they are of their answer, and the less specific answer should be recorded too. This will ensure subsequent investigations are not misdirected by inaccurate or uncertain information.

Not pushing for an answer

Hints and tips from existing guidance

Explain to the witness that, if you ask a question they do not understand, or one they do not know the answer to, they should say so – it is acceptable to say 'I don’t know' or 'I don’t understand'.

Hints and tips from the front line

One practitioner indicated that, when taking an initial account from a child, they would tell them it’s OK if they don’t remember. They felt this would help to reassure them during the initial account process.