Supporting professional discretion in decision making

Page contents

Page contents

Click on the links below to jump to the respective piece of content on this page.

How supervisors can encourage their staff to use their professional judgement.

First published
Effective supervision

Supervisors should encourage their staff to recognise where they can use their professional judgement and explore new and different ways of working by:

  • supporting staff to develop the skills to improve their decision making
  • helping staff to reflect on, and learn from, experience
  • encouraging staff to be innovative and use discretion where appropriate

Evidence summary

There was good research evidence suggesting a positive association between allowing discretion and staff wellbeing, job satisfaction and commitment. Research from other sectors also identified a link between influencing decisions at work and lower risk of burnout.

Enabling empowerment of team members is a feature of supportive leadership (see Introduction), which is associated with a range of positive staff outcomes, including higher levels of wellbeing, ethical behaviour, discretionary effort, engagement, emotional energy and job satisfaction. Empowering approaches, such as supporting, recognising, delegating and consulting, are also shown to be positively associated with wellbeing, job satisfaction, commitment, performance, conscientiousness and employees feeling able to give constructive ideas and opinions.

Practice evidence suggested that staff wanted to be creative and try new ways of working, but often felt restrained from doing so by the organisational culture.

Empirical evidence
Moderate
Practitioner evidence
Available

Supervisors should support their staff to use the national decision model to enable them to make informed and ethical decisions. Supervisors should also use the model to review decisions and actions with their staff, and to promote learning. Supervisors should also consider the use of reflective practice to support staff to reflect on and learn from their own experiences (see Supporting the delivery of good service). The Police (Conduct) Regulations 2020 encourage a culture of continuous self-reflection and learning.

Was this page useful?

Do not provide personal information such as your name or email address in the feedback form. Read our privacy policy for more information on how we use this data

What is the reason for your answer?
I couldn't find what I was looking for
The information wasn't relevant to me
The information is too complicated
Other